Pil Tinnitus
by WendellChrylser on 2010-05-08The Phoenix Concert Theatre - TorontoRating: 4 out of 5John Lydon is a remarkable person. He has fronted two of the most influential bands of the last 40 years and made great music. For me, the old PiL (up to Flowers of Romance) is absolutely brilliant while later stuff is totally throw-away and this show mixed the two, so I was alternately glued to the band and wandering around looking for something to do. The music from 2nd Edition is really quite incredible and it's great to see it played live ... the odd thing is seeing it played by a band of hired guns rather than the originals. I don't think the Lydon of the early 80's would have even considered such an idea feasible, but he has always found ways to keep relevant. These guys are great players and it's wonderful to hear the songs, but it's all maybe a little too perfect for my tastes. All Lydon things have been about unpredictability and the Wobbe/Levene PiL was a band ready to fly apart at any moment ... not this band. They will play their set perfectly and, other than Lydon, without attitude.
Lydon, on the other hand, does a heck of a job of convincing the crowd that he's still "on the leading edge" ... which is weird. He's doing the nostalgia circuit (another thing I doubt that he wants to admit), but demanding the respect of an innovator. He did manage to get a big crowd (pretty much sold out) of 50 year olds to yell "anger is an energy" over and over again ... I think a lot of them were probably actually thinking "it's past my bed time and you haven't innovated since I was 20". But he's a commanding presence.
If you never seen PiL, by all means experience it. If you saw them "back in the day" you need to be warned that this show will make you think a lot ... how long after the fact can you claim to be an innovator, and how much can you demand of the fans when you're doing the nostalgia circuit?